Greedy Trial Lawyer
Five U.S. Supreme Court Justices Need To Return To Earth
Category: The Latest Baddest
It is official - five of the justices of the U.S. Supreme Court are living on another planet.
The Supreme Court's doctrine of tough luckKEITH BOWLES was convicted of murder in an Ohio state court and sentenced to 15 years to life in prison. As was his right, Mr. Bowles challenged his conviction in federal court. He lost, though the judge and the clerk in the case didn't let him know before the deadline for appealing. When he learned of the ruling, Mr. Bowles asked for extra time. The judge agreed -- and gave Mr. Bowles 17 days. Mr. Bowles filed his notice of appeal 16 days later. Trouble was, despite the judge's instructions, the law that sets out the time frame for such actions provides for only a 14-day extension. On Thursday, the Supreme Court, splitting 5 to 4, threw out Mr. Bowles's claim, ruling that even though he had complied with the judge's order, he was still too late.
The majority opinion, by Justice Clarence Thomas, insisted that the court was left with no choice but to dismiss the case; these time limits, Justice Thomas said, are "jurisdictional," and failing to comply with them, for whatever reason, divests courts of the ability to hear the claim. In less legalistic language: tough luck.
In fact, as the dissent by Justice David H. Souter pointed out, the majority was not in any way bound to reach this manifestly unjust result; indeed, it had to ignore and overrule precedents to keep Mr. Bowles out of court.
"It is intolerable for the judicial system to treat people this way, and there is not even a technical justification for condoning this bait and switch," Justice Souter wrote. It "certainly seems reasonable to rely on an order from a federal judge," he noted -- "unless every statement by a federal court is to be tagged with the warning 'Beware of the Judge.' "
Beware of this court may be more like it.
Excerpts from an editorial in the Washington Post
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.greedytriallawyer.com/admin/mt-tb.cgi/571